QSuper Review

Founded in 1913, QSuper is a super fund and linked primarily to employees of the Queensland Government.
In 2022 they merged with Sunsuper to form Australian Retirement Trust.
As of March 31st 2026 the QSuper portion of the fund had approximately 730,310 members and $151.88 billion in assets under management.

Please Note: Any advice on this page is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether this is right for you. See full disclaimer.

Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance.

QSuper

QSuper Performance

QSuper has mostly underperformed the benchmark Across their main investment options in some cases by a considerable margin.  
Select an investment option from the menu below to see performance Vs the relevant median.
For a comparison against all other funds see compare super funds.

QSuper Fees

Fees for QSuper’s main investment options are lower than the median of other options of the same risk profile on Review My Super.
Select an investment option from the menu below to see flat fees, percentage based fees and total fees on a balance of $50,000. 

Returns to September 30 2026

Investment Option 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year
Australian Retirement Trust - Super Savings - Balanced 5.03% 9.79% 7.16%
Median 6.3% 10% 6.7%
Australian Retirement Trust - Super Savings - Balanced VS Median -1.27% -0.21% 0.46%

Fees

Investment Option Flat Fee Percentage Based Fee Fee Based on 50k
Australian Retirement Trust - Super Savings - Balanced 57.2 0.7% $407.2

Asset Allocation

RankAsset%
1 Australian Shares 25%
2 International Shares 26.75%
3 Fixed Interest 15.25%
4 Alternative 24%
5 Property 8%
6 Cash 1%

Returns to September 30 2026

Investment Option 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Lifetime - Lifetime Aspire 1 6.38% 10.54% 6.16%
Median 7.2% 11.7% 7.7%
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Lifetime - Lifetime Aspire 1 VS Median -0.82% -1.16% -1.54%

Fees

Investment Option Flat Fee Percentage Based Fee Fee Based on 50k
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Lifetime - Lifetime Aspire 1 57.2 0.58% $347.2

Asset Allocation

RankAsset%
1 Australian Shares 31.25%
2 International Shares 34%
3 Fixed Interest 1.75%
4 Alternative 24%
5 Property 8%
6 Cash 1%

Returns to September 30 2026

Investment Option 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year
Australian Retirement Trust - Super Savings - Lifecycle Cash Pool 3.98% 4.14% 3.3%
Median - - -
Australian Retirement Trust - Super Savings - Lifecycle Cash Pool VS Median 3.98% 4.14% 3.3%

Fees

Investment Option Flat Fee Percentage Based Fee Fee Based on 50k
Australian Retirement Trust - Super Savings - Lifecycle Cash Pool 57.2 0.23% $172.2

Asset Allocation

RankAsset%
1 Cash 100%

Returns to September 30 2026

Investment Option 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year
Australian Retirement Trust - Super Savings - Conservative 2.7% 5.68% 3.96%
Median 3.8% 6.3% 4%
Australian Retirement Trust - Super Savings - Conservative VS Median -1.1% -0.62% -0.04%

Fees

Investment Option Flat Fee Percentage Based Fee Fee Based on 50k
Australian Retirement Trust - Super Savings - Conservative 57.2 0.66% $387.2

Asset Allocation

RankAsset%
1 Australian Shares 8.5%
2 International Shares 7.5%
3 Fixed Interest 46%
4 Alternative 22.5%
5 Property 7.5%
6 Cash 8%

Returns to September 30 2026

Investment Option 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year
Australian Retirement Trust - Super Savings - Lifecycle Balanced Pool 5.03% 9.62% 7.04%
Median 6.3% 10% 6.7%
Australian Retirement Trust - Super Savings - Lifecycle Balanced Pool VS Median -1.27% -0.38% 0.34%

Fees

Investment Option Flat Fee Percentage Based Fee Fee Based on 50k
Australian Retirement Trust - Super Savings - Lifecycle Balanced Pool 57.2 0.7% $407.2

Asset Allocation

RankAsset%
1 Australian Shares 25%
2 International Shares 26.75%
3 Fixed Interest 15.25%
4 Alternative 24%
5 Property 8%
6 Cash 1%

Returns to September 30 2026

Investment Option 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year
Australian Retirement Trust - Super Savings - Socially Conscious Balanced 6.07% 10.17% 6.95%
Median 6.3% 10% 6.7%
Australian Retirement Trust - Super Savings - Socially Conscious Balanced VS Median -0.23% 0.17% 0.25%

Fees

Investment Option Flat Fee Percentage Based Fee Fee Based on 50k
Australian Retirement Trust - Super Savings - Socially Conscious Balanced 57.2 0.8% $457.2

Asset Allocation

RankAsset%
1 Australian Shares 25%
2 International Shares 28%
3 Fixed Interest 17%
4 Alternative 14%
5 Property 14%
6 Cash 2%

Returns to September 30 2026

Investment Option 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Lifetime - Lifetime Sustain 2 3.49% 6.87% 4.14%
Median 5.2% 8.4% 5.4%
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Lifetime - Lifetime Sustain 2 VS Median -1.71% -1.53% -1.26%

Fees

Investment Option Flat Fee Percentage Based Fee Fee Based on 50k
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Lifetime - Lifetime Sustain 2 57.2 0.42% $267.2

Asset Allocation

RankAsset%
1 Australian Shares 17.25%
2 International Shares 18.75%
3 Fixed Interest 45.75%
4 Alternative 13.25%
5 Property 4.5%
6 Cash 0.5%

Returns to September 30 2026

Investment Option 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Lifetime - Lifetime Focus 2 3.84% 8.17% 4.4%
Median 6.3% 10% 6.7%
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Lifetime - Lifetime Focus 2 VS Median -2.46% -1.83% -2.3%

Fees

Investment Option Flat Fee Percentage Based Fee Fee Based on 50k
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Lifetime - Lifetime Focus 2 57.2 0.5% $307.2

Asset Allocation

RankAsset%
1 Australian Shares 23.5%
2 International Shares 25.5%
3 Fixed Interest 26.5%
4 Alternative 17.75%
5 Property 6%
6 Cash 0.75%

Returns to September 30 2026

Investment Option 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Lifetime - Lifetime Focus 1 4.85% 9.11% 5.11%
Median 6.3% 10% 6.7%
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Lifetime - Lifetime Focus 1 VS Median -1.45% -0.89% -1.59%

Fees

Investment Option Flat Fee Percentage Based Fee Fee Based on 50k
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Lifetime - Lifetime Focus 1 57.2 0.52% $317.2

Asset Allocation

RankAsset%
1 Australian Shares 26.5%
2 International Shares 29%
3 Fixed Interest 16.5%
4 Alternative 20.25%
5 Property 7%
6 Cash 0.75%

Returns to September 30 2026

Investment Option 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Lifetime - Lifetime Aspire 2 4.26% 8.87% 4.54%
Median 6.3% 10% 6.7%
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Lifetime - Lifetime Aspire 2 VS Median -2.04% -1.13% -2.16%

Fees

Investment Option Flat Fee Percentage Based Fee Fee Based on 50k
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Lifetime - Lifetime Aspire 2 57.2 0.52% $317.2

Asset Allocation

RankAsset%
1 Australian Shares 26.5%
2 International Shares 29%
3 Fixed Interest 16.5%
4 Alternative 20.25%
5 Property 7%
6 Cash 0.75%

Returns to September 30 2026

Investment Option 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Lifetime - Lifetime Sustain 1 3.81% 7.42% 4.49%
Median 5.2% 8.4% 5.4%
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Lifetime - Lifetime Sustain 1 VS Median -1.39% -0.98% -0.91%

Fees

Investment Option Flat Fee Percentage Based Fee Fee Based on 50k
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Lifetime - Lifetime Sustain 1 57.2 0.44% $277.2

Asset Allocation

RankAsset%
1 Australian Shares 18.75%
2 International Shares 20.25%
3 Fixed Interest 41.25%
4 Alternative 14.25%
5 Property 5%
6 Cash 0.5%

Returns to September 30 2026

Investment Option 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Lifetime - Lifetime Focus 3 2.89% 7.33% 3.71%
Median 5.2% 8.4% 5.4%
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Lifetime - Lifetime Focus 3 VS Median -2.31% -1.07% -1.69%

Fees

Investment Option Flat Fee Percentage Based Fee Fee Based on 50k
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Lifetime - Lifetime Focus 3 57.2 0.46% $287.2

Asset Allocation

RankAsset%
1 Australian Shares 20.25%
2 International Shares 22%
3 Fixed Interest 36.25%
4 Alternative 15.75%
5 Property 5%
6 Cash 0.75%

Returns to September 30 2026

Investment Option 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Lifetime - Lifetime Outlook 6.26% 10.48% 6.08%
Median 7.2% 11.7% 7.7%
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Lifetime - Lifetime Outlook VS Median -0.94% -1.22% -1.62%

Fees

Investment Option Flat Fee Percentage Based Fee Fee Based on 50k
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Lifetime - Lifetime Outlook 57.2 0.58% $347.2

Asset Allocation

RankAsset%
1 Australian Shares 31.25%
2 International Shares 34%
3 Fixed Interest 1.75%
4 Alternative 24%
5 Property 8%
6 Cash 1%

Returns to September 30 2026

Investment Option 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year
Australian Retirement Trust - Super Savings - High Growth 6.25% 11.1% 8.42%
Median 7.2% 11.7% 7.7%
Australian Retirement Trust - Super Savings - High Growth VS Median -0.95% -0.6% 0.72%

Fees

Investment Option Flat Fee Percentage Based Fee Fee Based on 50k
Australian Retirement Trust - Super Savings - High Growth 57.2 0.72% $417.2

Asset Allocation

RankAsset%
1 Australian Shares 31.25%
2 International Shares 34%
3 Fixed Interest 1.75%
4 Alternative 24%
5 Property 8%
6 Cash 1%

Returns to September 30 2026

Investment Option 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year
Australian Retirement Trust - Super Savings - Balanced 5.03% 9.79% 7.16%
Median 6.3% 10% 6.7%
Australian Retirement Trust - Super Savings - Balanced VS Median -1.27% -0.21% 0.46%

Fees

Investment Option Flat Fee Percentage Based Fee Fee Based on 50k
Australian Retirement Trust - Super Savings - Balanced 57.2 0.7% $407.2

Asset Allocation

RankAsset%
1 Australian Shares 25%
2 International Shares 26.75%
3 Fixed Interest 15.25%
4 Alternative 24%
5 Property 8%
6 Cash 1%

Returns to September 30 2026

Investment Option 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Accum. - Socially Conscious Balanced 6.07% - -
Median 6.3% - -
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Accum. - Socially Conscious Balanced VS Median -0.23% - -

Fees

Investment Option Flat Fee Percentage Based Fee Fee Based on 50k
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Accum. - Socially Conscious Balanced 57.2 0.76% $437.2

Asset Allocation

RankAsset%
1 Australian Shares 25%
2 International Shares 28%
3 Fixed Interest 17%
4 Alternative 14%
5 Property 14%
6 Cash 2%

Returns to September 30 2026

Investment Option 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Accum. - High Growth 6.25% - -
Median 7.2% - -
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Accum. - High Growth VS Median -0.95% - -

Fees

Investment Option Flat Fee Percentage Based Fee Fee Based on 50k
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Accum. - High Growth 57.2 0.68% $397.2

Asset Allocation

RankAsset%
1 Australian Shares 31.25%
2 International Shares 34%
3 Fixed Interest 1.75%
4 Alternative 24%
5 Property 8%
6 Cash 1%

Returns to September 30 2026

Investment Option 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Accum. - High Growth Index 7.61% - -
Median 7.2% - -
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Accum. - High Growth Index VS Median 0.41% - -

Fees

Investment Option Flat Fee Percentage Based Fee Fee Based on 50k
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Accum. - High Growth Index 57.2 0.21% $162.2

Asset Allocation

RankAsset%
1 Australian Shares 38.75%
2 International Shares 51.25%
3 Fixed Interest 10%

Returns to September 30 2026

Investment Option 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Accum. - Balanced 5.03% - -
Median 6.3% - -
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Accum. - Balanced VS Median -1.27% - -

Fees

Investment Option Flat Fee Percentage Based Fee Fee Based on 50k
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Accum. - Balanced 57.2 0.66% $387.2

Asset Allocation

RankAsset%
1 Australian Shares 25%
2 International Shares 26.75%
3 Fixed Interest 15.25%
4 Alternative 24%
5 Property 8%
6 Cash 1%

Returns to September 30 2026

Investment Option 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Accum. - Conservative-Balanced 3.81% - -
Median 5.2% - -
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Accum. - Conservative-Balanced VS Median -1.39% - -

Fees

Investment Option Flat Fee Percentage Based Fee Fee Based on 50k
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Accum. - Conservative-Balanced 57.2 0.64% $377.2

Asset Allocation

RankAsset%
1 Australian Shares 17.25%
2 International Shares 18.25%
3 Fixed Interest 33.5%
4 Alternative 22.5%
5 Property 7.5%
6 Cash 1%

Returns to September 30 2026

Investment Option 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Accum. - Conservative 2.7% - -
Median 3.8% - -
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Accum. - Conservative VS Median -1.1% - -

Fees

Investment Option Flat Fee Percentage Based Fee Fee Based on 50k
Australian Retirement Trust - QSuper Accum. - Conservative 57.2 0.62% $367.2

Asset Allocation

RankAsset%
1 Australian Shares 8.5%
2 International Shares 7.5%
3 Fixed Interest 46%
4 Alternative 22.5%
5 Property 7.5%
6 Cash 8%

Performance data: Lonsec. Median benchmarks: Chant West. Data is updated monthly; the reporting period is shown in the tables. Investment options are compared with the Chant West median for their risk profile.

Insurance


Whilst most members are offered default Death and Total and permanent Disablement Cover, they can also apply for Income Protection Cover.

Additional cover is available with the following limits:
Death – $3 million
TPD – $3 million.
Income protection – up to 87.75% of your income with a maximum of $50,000 per month.
Insurance is provided by QInsure Limited.

Insurance Rating

OmniLife
0 /100

Insurance rating by Omnilife. 
Please note: This is the overall rating before individual circumstances are taken into account. Individual circumstances will vary the rating significantly.

Fund details

See the QSuper ABN and USI page for all the information required to contribute to this fund.
Read their PDS and TMD for further details.

FAQ's

We use investment performance data supplied by Lonsec and median benchmarks supplied by Chant West, both updated monthly.

Each investment option is assigned to a Chant West risk profile based on its proportion of growth assets. We then compare its return with the median benchmark for that risk profile over the same reporting period.

The difference shown in the table is the investment option’s return minus the median return.

Grouping options by growth asset allocation helps make comparisons more accurate, although options within the same profile can still have different investments and risks. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance.

Member ratings and investment returns measure different things.

Member ratings reflect the experiences and opinions of people who submit reviews. These may relate to customer service, fees, insurance, administration or their satisfaction with investment performance.

Our performance tables compare an investment option’s reported returns with the relevant  benchmark over specified periods. A fund can therefore deliver above median returns while receiving poor reviews for service or insurance or receive positive reviews despite below median returns.

Submitted reviews may not represent the experience of all members. Consider them alongside performance data, fees, insurance features and the fund’s official documents.

QSuper Reviews

QSuper Reviews: 1.6 out of 5 stars from 23 customer reviews on Australia’s best superannuation review site Review My Super.

See more Super Fund Reviews to compare ratings and reviews across funds.

1.6 16 Reviews
How would you rate
2.1 15 Reviews
Service
1.8 15 Reviews
Performance
2.6 15 Reviews
Fees
1.9 11 Reviews
Insurance
1.2 14 Reviews
Transparency
guest
How would you rate
Service
Performance
Fees
Insurance
Transparency

23 Reviews
Most Votes
Newest Oldest
David
David
2 years ago
How would you rate :
     
Service :
     
Performance :
     
Fees :
     
Insurance :
     
Transparency :
     

When QSuper merged with SunSuper I feel QSuper members were completely misled. I hope the ombudsman’s office is investigating. If we are one find now why am I still in a QSuper balanced fund which has performed so poorly. All the pre-merge messaging was we were going to be one fund now but obviously that was misleading. BALANCED : ART 10% vs QSuper 4%. When I enquired about where all the losses have occurred in 23, I was initially given the long term investment message. I knew they had lost money but when I asked specifically which investments had returned negative results I was fobbed off. No transparency at all. At the members online seminar to calm disappointed QSuper members we were not given any meaningful explanation either I feel. Just lots of warm and fussy.

DESLEY Bartlett
DESLEY Bartlett
4 years ago
How would you rate :
     
Service :
     
Performance :
     
Fees :
     
Insurance :
     
Transparency :
     

Previously it was a safe fund with regular low growth but has this year it has performed very badly. No growth, in fact negative growth.

Anonymous
Anonymous
4 years ago
How would you rate :
     

I will get out of QSuper. Your fees are ridiculously high and your performance is so bad…

Anonymous
Anonymous
2 years ago
How would you rate :
     
Service :
     
Performance :
     
Fees :
     
Insurance :
     
Transparency :
     

Watch how quickly they draw the shutters when you question their transparency and request information. Profits first, members interests last….

LMAcC
LMAcC
1 year ago
How would you rate :
     
Service :
     
Performance :
     
Fees :
     
Insurance :
     
Transparency :
     

Q_Super Insurance customer service needs improvement, they do not answer phone calls, will not answer emails, never follow up after consultants informing you they will. Income protection service has dysfunctional staff. Consultants who answer pleasant, but to no avail, you are kept on a merry ground. They are not approachable as ignore all attempts of contact, Service Manager is always uncontactable.

Anonymous
Anonymous
4 years ago

ok

Anonymous
Anonymous
4 years ago
How would you rate :
     

The Self Invest portal is separate and very clunky. Needs major revision.

Anonymous
Anonymous
4 years ago
How would you rate :
     

needs to give more back and low fees

Anonymous
Anonymous
4 years ago
How would you rate :
     
Service :
     
Performance :
     
Fees :
     
Insurance :
     
Transparency :
     

fees to high

Anonymous
Anonymous
3 years ago
How would you rate :
     
Service :
     
Performance :
     
Fees :
     
Transparency :
     

Good investment returns but

Anonymous
Anonymous
3 years ago
How would you rate :
     

Have not received any super payments into my Qsuper account since the merger in Dec 2022. $$$thousand missing. Qsuper state it’s the work accountant problem and can not do anything while work say Qsuper are bouncing back the payments. I have contacted Qsuper several times but still going in circles for 3 months.

Anonymous
Anonymous
3 years ago
How would you rate :
     

They are just awful! They used to be really good before the privatisation. Stay away!

Anonymous
Anonymous
3 years ago
How would you rate :
     

Since merger with Sunsuper to form ART QSuper has been absorbed for commerccial growth objective. It is essentially finished.
Fees are rising performance sliding, and although the say ART , QSuper members are locked out of ART products unless you transfer funds which if you do , there would many more better industry options than ART or QSuper.

Anonymous
Anonymous
3 years ago
How would you rate :
     

Time to change I think.

Anonymous
Anonymous
3 years ago
How would you rate :
     
Service :
     
Performance :
     
Fees :
     

Performance returns are well below industry average for the Balanced Option and have been for a number of years. May be due to Qsuper moving to a defensive position about 8 years ago.. Check other funds before investing

Ross
Ross
3 years ago
How would you rate :
     
Service :
     
Performance :
     
Fees :
     
Insurance :
     
Transparency :
     

I find it hard to get someone who’s has a good knowledge of the QSuper product. Plus since Covid the service has gone down hill most of the staff are working from home and have to place you on hold for long periods of time.

Julie Donald
Julie Donald
3 years ago
How would you rate :
     
Service :
     
Performance :
     
Fees :
     
Insurance :
     
Transparency :
     

Income Protection insurance is one of those fake insurances, especially the extra unitised cover that I paid for. 30 day claims are false. 3 months later and still no income protection payments made. Super going backwards.

Anonymous
Anonymous
3 years ago
How would you rate :
     
Service :
     
Performance :
     
Fees :
     
Insurance :
     
Transparency :
     

Leaving this fund…really poor performance and customer service really bad.It seems anyone I spoke with was inexperienced and could not explain fees or returns. A promise of a call back didn’t happen.A terrible return last year and also so far negative this year when my partner is with Australian Trust which is meant to be the same fund and his returns twice as good as mine.

Anonymous
Anonymous
2 years ago
How would you rate :
     
Service :
     
Performance :
     
Fees :
     
Insurance :
     
Transparency :
     

High fees, very poor returns compared with other funds.

Anonymous
Anonymous
2 years ago
How would you rate :
     
Service :
     
Performance :
     
Fees :
     
Transparency :
     

I always found call staff in Q Super helpful but that’s no where near as important to me as fund performance.
And that’s where the Q Super Fund has crashed..
Their investment team’s performance is woeful- delivering ongoing poor returns. This is coupled with a now too-high fee structure.
I left them some time ago for a better industry fund, and am very glad I did.

JOHN KELLEHEAR
JOHN KELLEHEAR
2 years ago
How would you rate :
     
Service :
     
Performance :
     
Fees :
     
Transparency :
     

Changed to QSuper 2 years ago when they were boasting about how good they would be after the merge with Sunsuper – well that was a mistake – absolutely dropped the ball – no merger – just acquisition – poor performance with next to no gain.
The fund I left is equivalent to $50k higher after 2 years than QSuper. ANZ performed better by ~4% ($30k).
Time to look for a better Super Fund – won’t be hard.

Ian
Ian
2 years ago
How would you rate :
     
Service :
     
Performance :
     
Fees :
     
Insurance :
     
Transparency :
     

I invested in their Q Super lifetime pension product a year ago. Now I’m stuck with a poor performing fund and diminishing pension payments as compared to inflation. The performance isn’t even close to other funds. No option to switch. Why can’t the Lifetime Pension Pool be invested in ART Balanced Fund? Not happy.

Andrew Horgan
Andrew Horgan
1 year ago
How would you rate :
     
Service :
     
Performance :
     
Fees :
     
Insurance :
     
Transparency :
     

QSuper used to be Great and I have been a Long Term Member since 1989
But since being taken over by Australian Retirement Trust (ART) QSuper are absolutely Useless !
QSuper completely neglect their Self Invest option now and look to be actively trying to shut it down and so continually winding down what Assets you can hold ASX300 => ASX100 for example !
And they completely Fail to inform Members of Any such changes.
If you want more control over your Super without going completely to an SMF then QSuper has removed itself from the equation !!!
On top of that their response times are simply ludicrous !
3 days to answer an email and 45 days to respond to any sort of complaint !
I’d still go with an Industry Fund but there are now much better options than QSuper/ART !

Last edited 1 year ago by Andrew Horgan
QSuper
23
0
Would love your thoughts, please review.x